top of page
  • Winnipeg Tribune

The Rise of Polarizing Figures in Provincial Politics

Winnipeg, October 10. 2023 - Manitobans find themselves at a crossroads, facing a future led by a group of politicians who, despite their fervent activism, raise serious questions about their ability to govern effectively. The recent election results have ushered in a new era, one characterized by the rise of Wab Kinew and his team of passionate yet divisive activists. While diversity and inclusion are undeniably important in politics, the qualifications and temperament of our elected representatives cannot be overlooked.

One of the contentious figures in this new government is Uzoma Asagwara, whose vocal advocacy for defunding the police raises concerns about public safety. While there are valid conversations to be had about police reform, a blanket approach to defunding law enforcement without considering the potential consequences is reckless. A responsible leader must balance the need for reform with the imperative of maintaining public safety.

Logan Oxenham's victory is celebrated as a triumph for the trans community. However, the lack of transparency surrounding Oxenham's gender identity during the campaign raises questions about honesty and integrity. Open and honest communication with constituents is fundamental to a functioning democracy. Voters deserve transparency from their elected officials, regardless of their gender identity or background.

Nahanni Fontaine's propensity for verbal attacks on social media raises concerns about professionalism and respectful discourse. A leader should inspire unity, not division, fostering a culture of respectful dialogue even in the face of disagreements. Fontaine's approach threatens to further polarize an already divided political landscape.

Bernadette Smith's proposals to decriminalize narcotics and establish safe injection sites, while well-intentioned, raise legitimate concerns about the potential impact on public health and safety. A comprehensive approach to addressing addiction must prioritize prevention, treatment, and rehabilitation, rather than simply providing free drugs. Such policies demand careful consideration and expert input to avoid unintended consequences.

The big question looming over Manitoba now is: who among these newly elected MLAs is truly qualified to be a Minister of the province? The gravitas required for this role goes beyond activism and passion. It demands a deep understanding of governance, diplomacy, and the ability to make tough decisions for the greater good. While the enthusiasm of these politicians is commendable, it must be matched by a nuanced understanding of the complexities of leading a province.

This new wave of NDP politicians in Manitoba marks a departure from the legacy of leaders like Gary Doer, who balanced progressive policies with practical governance. Manitobans deserve representatives who are not only passionate advocates for their causes but also capable administrators with a proven track record of effective leadership.

As the province navigates the next four years under this new leadership, it is imperative that Manitobans hold their elected officials accountable. Democracy thrives when citizens actively engage in the political process, demanding transparency, honesty, and competency from those who represent them. Only through active participation and critical scrutiny can we ensure that Manitoba's future remains bright, prosperous, and united.


bottom of page